Javed Akhtar's speech at the India Today Conclave:
I am quite sure ladies and gentlemen, that in this august assembly nobody would envy my position at this moment. Speaking after such a charismatic and formidable personality like Sri Sri Ravi Shankar is like coming out of the pavilion to play after Tendulkar has made a sparkling century. But in some weak moment I had committed myself.
There are certain things that I would like to make very clear at the very outset. Don’t get carried away by my name – Javed Akhtar. I am not revealing a secret, I am saying something that I have said many times, in writing or on TV, in public…I am an atheist, I have no religious beliefs. And obviously I don’t believe in spirituality of some kind. Some kind.
Another thing. I am not standing here to criticize, analyze, or attack this gentleman who is sitting here. We have a very pleasant, civilized relation. I have always found him to be an extremely courteous person.
One is talking about an idea, an attitude, a mindset. Not any individual.
I must tell you that when Rajeev opened this session, for a moment I felt that I have come to the wrong place. Because, if we are discussing the philosophy of Krishan and Gautam and Kabir, Vivekanand, then I have nothing to say. I can sit down right now. I am not here to discuss a glorious past of which I suppose every Indian is proud, and rightly so. I am here to discuss a dubious present.
India Today has invited me and I have come here to talk of spirituality today. Let’s not be confused by this word spirituality, you can find two people with the same name and they can be totally different people. Ram Charit Manas was written by Tulsidas. And the television film has been made by Ramanand Sagar. Ramayan is common but I don’t think it would be very wise to club Tulsidas with Ramanand Sagar. I remember, when he had written Ramcharit Manas, he had faced a kind of a social boycott. How could he write a holy book in such a language like Avadhi? Sometimes I wonder fundamentalists of all hues and all colors, religions and communities…how similar they are. In 1798, a gentleman called Shah Abdul Qadir, in this very city, for the first time translated Quran in Urdu, and all the ulemas of that time gave fatwa against him that how could he translate this holy book in such a heathen language.
When Tulsi wrote Ramcharit Manas and he was boycotted, I remember a chowpai that he had written.
“Dhut kaho abdhut kaho rajput kaho ki julawa kohu
Kohu ki beti se beta na biahab, kohu ki jaat bigaar na chahu
Mang ke khaibo, mehjid ma raihbo, lebe ka ek na debe ka dohu”
Ramanand Sagar, when he made his television serial, he made millions. I am not undermining him, but obviously he is much lower in the rung.
I will give you another example. Perhaps it would be more direct and more appropriate. Gautam came out of a palace and went into wilderness to find the truth. But nowadays we see, the modern age gurus, come out of the wilderness and wind up in the palaces. They are moving in the opposite direction. We can’t talk of them in the same breath. So let us not hide behind names which are dear and respectable for every Indian.
When I was invited to give this talk, I felt that yes, I am an atheist, try to be a rationalist in any given situation, Maybe that’s why I have been called. But suddenly I have realized that there is another quality that I share with Modern Age gurus. I work in films. We have lot in common. Both of us, sell dreams, both of us create illusions, both of us create icons, but with a difference. After three hours we put a placard – the end. Go back to reality. They don’t.
So ladies and gentlemen, let me make it very clear that I have come to talk of this spirituality that has a supermarket in the world. Arms, drugs and spirituality – these are the three big businesses in the world. But in arms and drugs you really have to do something, give something. That’s the difference. Here you don’t have to give anything.
In this supermarket you get instant Nirvana, Moksha by mail, a crash course in self realization, cosmic consciousness in four easy lessons. This supermarket has its chain all over the world, where the restless elite buy spiritual fast food. I am talking about this spirituality.
Plato in his dialogues has said many a wise thing, and one of them is – before starting any discussion decide on the meanings of words. Let us try to decide on the meaning of this word spirituality. Does it mean love for mankind that transcends all religion, caste, creed, race? Is that so? Then I have no problem. Except that I call it humanity. Does it mean love of plants, trees, mountains, oceans, rivers, animals? The non-human world? If that is so, again I have no problem at all. Except that I call it environmental consciousness. Does spirituality mean heartfelt regard for social institutions like marriage, parenthood, fine arts, judiciary, freedom of expression. I have no problem again sir, how can I disagree here? I call it civil responsibility. Does spirituality mean going into your own world trying to understand the meaning of your own life? Who can object on that? I call it self-introspection, self assessment. Does spirituality mean Yoga? Thanks to Patanjali, who has given us the details of Yoga, Yam, Yatam, aasan, pranayam…We may do it under any name, but if we are doing pranayam, wonderful. I call it healthcare. Physical fitness.
Now is it a matter of only semantics. If all this is spirituality, then what is the discussion. All these words that I have used are extremely respectable and totally acceptable words. There is nothing abstract or intangible about them. So why stick to this word spirituality? What is there in spirituality that has not been covered by all these words? Is there something? If that is so then what is that?
Somebody in return can ask me what is my problem with this word. I am asking to change it, leave it, drop it, make it obsolete but why so? I will tell you what is my reservation. If spirituality means all this then there is no discussion. But there is something else which makes me uneasy. In a dictionary, the meaning of spirituality is rooted in a word called “spirit”. When mankind didn’t know whether this earth is round or flat, he had decided that human beings are actually the combination of two things. Body and spirit. Body is temporary, it dies. But the spirit is, shall I say, non-biodegradable. In your body you have a liver and heart and intestines and the brain, but since the brain is a part of the body, and mind lies within the brain, it is inferior because ultimately the brain too shall die with the body, but don’t worry, you are not going to die, because you are your spirit, and the spirit has the supreme consciousness that will remain, and whatever problem you have is because you listen to your mind. Stop listening to your mind. Listen to your spirit - the supreme consciousness that knows the cosmic truth. All right. It’s not surprising that in Pune there is an ashram and I used to go there. I loved the oratory. On the gate of the lecture hall there was a placard. Leave your shoes and minds here. There are other gurus who don’t mind if you carry your shoes. But minds?…sorry.
Now, if you leave your mind what do you do? You need the Guru to find the next station of consciousness. That hides somewhere in the spirit. He has reached the supreme consciousness, he knows the supreme truth. But can he tell you. No sir, he cannot tell you. So can you find out on your own? No sir, you need the guru for that. You need him but he cannot guarantee that you will know the ultimate truth… and what is that ultimate truth? What is the cosmic truth? Relating to cosmos? I have really not been able to understand that. The moment we step out of the solar system the first star is Alpha.Centueri It is just four light years away. How do I relate to that!! What do I do!!
So the emperor is wearing robes that only the wise can see. And the emperor is becoming bigger and bigger. And there are more and more wise people who are appreciating the robe.
I used to think that actually spirituality is the second line of defence for the religious people. When they get embarrassed about traditional religion, when it starts looking too down-market, they hide behind this smokescreen of cosmos and super consciousness. But that is not the complete truth. Because the clientele of traditional religion and spirituality is different. You take the map of the world, you start marking places which are extremely religious, within India or outside India, Asia, Latin America, Europe…wherever. You will find that wherever there is lot of religion there is lack of human rights. There is repression. Anywhere. Our Marxist friends used to say that religion is the opium of poor masses, the sigh of the oppressed. I don’t want to get into that discussion. But spirituality nowadays is definitely the tranquilizer of the rich.
You see that the clientele is well heeled, it is the affluent class. Alright, so the guru gets power, high self esteem, status, wealth…(which is not that important), power…and lot of wealth too. What does the disciple get? When I looked at them carefully I realized that there are categories and categories of these disciples. It’s not a monolith. There are different kinds of followers. Different kinds of disciples. One, who is rich, successful, doing extremely well in his life, making money, gaining property. Now, since he has everything he wants absolution too. So guru tells him - whatever you are doing, is “niskaam karma” – you are playing a role, this is all “Maya”, the money that you are making everyday and the property that you are acquiring, you are not emotionally involved with it. You are just playing a role. You come to me because you are in search of eternal truth. Maybe your hands are dirty, but your spirit and soul are pure. And this man, he starts feeling wonderful about himself. For seven days he is exploiting the world, and at the end of the seven days when he goes and sits at the feet of the guru, he feels – I am a sensitive person.
There is another category. That too comes from the affluent class. But he is not the winner like the first one. You know winning or losing that is also relative. A rickshaw-wallah if he is gambling on the pavement and wins hundred rupees will feel victorious, and if a corporate man makes only 300 million dollars, while his brother is a billionaire, he will feel like a failure. Now, what does this rich failure do? He needs a guru to tell him – who says that you have failed? You have other worlds, you have another vision, you have other sensibility that your brother doesn’t have. He thinks that he is successful…wrong. The world is very cruel, you know. The world tells you honestly, no sir, you have got three out of ten. The other person has seven out of ten. Fair. They will treat you that way and they will meet you that way. There he gets compassion. There he plays another game.
Another category. And I will talk about this category not with contempt or with any sense of superiority, not any bitterness, but all the compassion available one that is a very big client of this modern day guru and today’s spirituality, is the unhappy rich wife.
Here is a person who put all her individuality, aspirations and dreams, and her being at the altar of marriage and in return she got an indifferent husband. Who at the most gave her a couple of children. Who is rather busy with his work, or busy with other women. This woman needs a shoulder. She knows that she is an existential failure. There is nothing to look forward to. She has a vacuous, empty, comfortable yet purposeless life. It’s sad, but it is true.
Then there are other people. Who are suddenly traumatized. They lose a child. The wife dies. The husband dies. Or they lose the property, they lose their business. Something happens that shocks them and they ask – why me? So who do they ask? They go to the Guru. And the guru tells him that this is Karma. But there is another world if you follow me. Where there is no pain. Where there is no death. Where there is immortality. Where there is only bliss. He tells all these unhappy souls – follow me and I will take you to the heaven, to the paradise, where there is no pain. I am sorry sir, it is disappointing but true that there is no such paradise. Life will always have a certain quota of pain, of hurts, a possibility of defeats. But they do get some satisfaction.
Somebody may ask me if they are feeling better, if they are getting peace then what is your problem. It reminds me of a story that I have read. It’s an old Indian story told by a sage, that a hungry dog finds a dry bone and tries to eat it and in the process bites its own tongue. And the tongue is bleeding and the dog feels that he is getting nourishment from the bone.
I feel sad. I don’t want them, these adults, to behave like this because I respect them. Drugs and alcohol are also supposed to give mental peace and serenity, but is that kind of piece or serenity desirable or advisable? The answer is no. Any mental peace that is not anchored in rational thoughts is nothing but self-deception. Any serenity that takes you away from truth is just an illusion – a mirage. I know that there is a kind of a security in this which is like the security of a tri-cycle. If you are riding a tri-cycle you can’t fall. But adults do not ride tricycles. They ride bi-cycles. They can even fall. It is a part of life.
There is one more kind. Like everybody who is the member of the golf club is not fond of golf. In the same way everybody who is seen in an ashram is not a spiritual person. A film producer who is an ardent follower of a guru, whose ashram is about two hours from Delhi once told me that you must go to my Guru. You will see the who’s who of Delhi there. Let me tell you my Guruji is another Chandraswami in the making. Now this is a contact point for networking.
I have great respect for people who are spiritual, or religious, and in spite of this they are good people. And I have a reason. I believe that like every emotion or feeling, you have a limitation.
I am feeling slightly pressurized about time, can I get another five six minutes please…may I sir… Rajiv Mehrotra “yes you can”
You can see upto a point. And you can’t see further. You can hear upto a point, but beyond that you won’t be able to register sounds. You can mourn upto a point and then you will get over your mourning. You will feel happy upto a point and then you will be through with your happiness. Same way, I am sure that you have a certain capacity for nobility also. You can be as noble and no more. Now suppose if we count this capacity for nobility in the average man as ten units, now anybody who goes to pray in a mosque five times is consuming his five units, there anybody who goes to the temple or sits in the feet of the Guru, he is consuming his quota of nobility there. And in a totally non-productive manner. I don’t go to pray. I don’t pray. If I don’t go to any guru, or mosque or temple or church, what do I do with my quota of nobility. I will have to help somebody, feed somebody, give shelter to somebody. People who use their quota in worshipping, praying, adoring religious figures and spiritual figures, in spite of that, if they are left with some nobility, hats off to them.
You may ask me, that if I have this kind of ideas about religious people, why should I show such reverence for Krishan and Kabir and Gautam? You can ask me. I’ll tell you why I respect them. These were the great contributors in the human civilization. They were born in different points of time in history, in different situations. But one thing is common in them. They stood up against injustice. They fought for the downtrodden. Whether it was Ravana, or Kansha or the pharaoh or the high priests or the British Samrajya in front of Gandhi – or the communal empire of Firoze Tughlaq in the times of Kabir, they stood against that.
And what surprises me, and confirms my worst feelings, that today, the enlightened people who know the cosmic truth, none of them stand up against the powers that be. None of them raises his voice against the ruling classes and the privileged classes. Charity, yes, when it is approved and cleared by the establishment and the powers that be. But I want to know which was that guru which took the dalits to those temples which are still closed to them. I want to know which was that guru who stood for the rights of the Adivasis against the thekedaars and contractors. I want to know which was that guru who spoke about the victims of Gujarat and went to their relief camps. They are human beings.
Sir…It is not enough to teach the rich how to breathe. It is the rich mans recreation. It is the hypocrites’ pretension. It is a mischievous deception. And you know that in the oxford dictionary, mischievous deception is a term that is used for a word, and that word is…HOAX. Thank you.
Wednesday, May 5, 2010
Monday, May 3, 2010
Red red go away, come again no other day!
I wish Karl Marx was alive to see how his conceptual notions have been used, misused and abused day in day out here. The other day, someone asked me if i noticed any difference between Marxism and Maoism. And, I strongly said no- as I feel at an ideological level, its all abt class struggle. But I had a problem with the manifestations. Violence/killing CANNOT just be justified at any cost.
Killing people to gain visibility or to stake claim over scoring a point has no place in a civilized society.
74 CRPF jawans massacred in a naxal ambush in Dantewada!!!! Omigawd!
I just fail to understand why aren’t our security forces equipped and trained enough!!! Look at any developed nation and you would be surprised to see how their security personnel look like let alone the modern ammunition that they carry. And the political apathy!!! Guess a top-notch politician should fall prey to such mishap to ignite a stern action against people who take law and order into their hands and go on a killing spree.
This dantewada thing was a sheer mockery of intelligence, tactics, combat, preparedness, and the list goes on..................if media reports are anything to go by, the naxal folks were carrying sophisticated arms which makes one to believe that there is a much deeper and larger network which is outfoxing the intelligence of the country. And if this is not the case, then there might be some high level involvement ( well, this is just a speculation). One cannot ignore any permutation or combination when it comes to such a sensitive issue that is – security...I hang my head in shame the way we have created a hero in kasab ( just because there was a cross-border intrusion) and have given clod eye to our internal enemies..
I must submit that i have very limited reading to the cause that some people are fighting for. But then, i just cannot see them let free with a license to kill ( am sure they think so).
Less than two years ago, I lost a very good friend of mine to such dastardly act. It was a huge personal loss and I can only feel for the families of the deceased. Destiny of such people who are in the noble cause of saving the motherland is written in such a fashion-----well, I can just offer my dry prayers. Wish I could do more.....
Killing people to gain visibility or to stake claim over scoring a point has no place in a civilized society.
74 CRPF jawans massacred in a naxal ambush in Dantewada!!!! Omigawd!
I just fail to understand why aren’t our security forces equipped and trained enough!!! Look at any developed nation and you would be surprised to see how their security personnel look like let alone the modern ammunition that they carry. And the political apathy!!! Guess a top-notch politician should fall prey to such mishap to ignite a stern action against people who take law and order into their hands and go on a killing spree.
This dantewada thing was a sheer mockery of intelligence, tactics, combat, preparedness, and the list goes on..................if media reports are anything to go by, the naxal folks were carrying sophisticated arms which makes one to believe that there is a much deeper and larger network which is outfoxing the intelligence of the country. And if this is not the case, then there might be some high level involvement ( well, this is just a speculation). One cannot ignore any permutation or combination when it comes to such a sensitive issue that is – security...I hang my head in shame the way we have created a hero in kasab ( just because there was a cross-border intrusion) and have given clod eye to our internal enemies..
I must submit that i have very limited reading to the cause that some people are fighting for. But then, i just cannot see them let free with a license to kill ( am sure they think so).
Less than two years ago, I lost a very good friend of mine to such dastardly act. It was a huge personal loss and I can only feel for the families of the deceased. Destiny of such people who are in the noble cause of saving the motherland is written in such a fashion-----well, I can just offer my dry prayers. Wish I could do more.....
Tuesday, April 6, 2010
Ooof yeh mohabbat !!!
For over a week now, the news of the possible sania-shoaib tie-up has been all over the places. With who-knows-who-is-this Ayesha from Hyderabad, the i-will-decide-everything Thackres from Mumbai, we-also-exist fundamentalists and rest interested for a masaladaar news leaving no room for better sense to prevail, I am sure this episode is gonna travel some miles albeit crossing that do-not-touch-me indo-pak border. I will not be surprised if white house issues a statement offering to mediate this (ye)S-(ye)S tie-up.
Well, sania has always been media’s darling for whatever she does or does not do. Such a poor thing for the Hyderabad lass. I remember her speaking to the British media post a match at Wimbledon and she handled so beautifully a sensitive question on her religious affiliation and her tennis attire inviting ire of some self proclaimed custodians of a belief back in India. I was taken completely aback. What a matured and responsible answer and the Brit chapie appeared scratching his head !!! And I just loved the way she spoke. But sadly, her tennis (the best in the class for and from the Indian sub-continent) amidst everything, unfortunately had to fall prey. Am sure many tennis lovers would have been disappointed beyond description.
Ever since she broke into the intl tennis circuit, the poor girl has been subjected to kitna kuchh. How stupid- others had to take a call on what she had to wear on the court!!Q. I wish someone could dare saying that to the Kurnikovas and Williams. Next time when an Indian goes to compete with Usain Bolt, he would be asked to run with a lungi or a dhoti on. And why not try heptathlon in the commonwealth games wearing saree. But then, who to blame!!! We Indians are so hell bent on calling the heads of people that make us hold our own high in pride.
Now Uddhab and Balasaheb are singing contradicting tunes on someone’s personal decision ! man, some people are so pata-nehin-kya-type. Worse, these are the people whom we choose, select and elect to script the destiny of a billion.
But for a change, a non-politician’s personal life hugging so much limelight in India is certainly a sign of progress .
Why cannot we leave two people alone to decide what they want (not) to do (well within the legal framework)? Doesn’t my land give me a right to my private life?
Well, sania has always been media’s darling for whatever she does or does not do. Such a poor thing for the Hyderabad lass. I remember her speaking to the British media post a match at Wimbledon and she handled so beautifully a sensitive question on her religious affiliation and her tennis attire inviting ire of some self proclaimed custodians of a belief back in India. I was taken completely aback. What a matured and responsible answer and the Brit chapie appeared scratching his head !!! And I just loved the way she spoke. But sadly, her tennis (the best in the class for and from the Indian sub-continent) amidst everything, unfortunately had to fall prey. Am sure many tennis lovers would have been disappointed beyond description.
Ever since she broke into the intl tennis circuit, the poor girl has been subjected to kitna kuchh. How stupid- others had to take a call on what she had to wear on the court!!Q. I wish someone could dare saying that to the Kurnikovas and Williams. Next time when an Indian goes to compete with Usain Bolt, he would be asked to run with a lungi or a dhoti on. And why not try heptathlon in the commonwealth games wearing saree. But then, who to blame!!! We Indians are so hell bent on calling the heads of people that make us hold our own high in pride.
Now Uddhab and Balasaheb are singing contradicting tunes on someone’s personal decision ! man, some people are so pata-nehin-kya-type. Worse, these are the people whom we choose, select and elect to script the destiny of a billion.
But for a change, a non-politician’s personal life hugging so much limelight in India is certainly a sign of progress .
Why cannot we leave two people alone to decide what they want (not) to do (well within the legal framework)? Doesn’t my land give me a right to my private life?
Friday, April 2, 2010
abt pens, pensils and notebooks....
For a country which got its independent identity over six decades ago, right to education for its citizens in 2010 fails to appeal me as a welcome move...am not undermining the imp of edn here. Rather i think this should have been done in 1951 itself.
Any ways, better late than never.with ppl like m m singh and kapil sibal at the helm of affairs, i have reasons to believe that the education landscape of India wud be like never before. nowithstanding what oppsn wud say, what some fanatic activists wud say, sibal seems to be in a hurry. and his being in a hurry gets my 'thumbs up'. man, u have the balls to do things this way.
however, we keep on hearing abt tall talks on 'balanced growth', 'social democracy', 'participatory development' and guess what, 4 days ago a friend asked me - what is 'positive development'..boy oh boy- what non-sensical things we guys are into !!!
Don't we realise its time we did the talk......enuf of talking and walking the talks..
With right to education all set to boost the GER ( Gross enrolment ratio) what confuses me is the meeting of RTE and 'compulsory education-CE'...Does this 'compulsory' element invite punishment for parents for not sending their children to schools? Does this also imply punitive action against primary school teachers for not getting eligible kids in their catchment areas to the schools? will RTE and CE put together create rooms for more corrupt practices? will the 'learning aid', 'food', etc reach the beneficiaries or will this mean more money for you-know-who ?
Many such questions are not eyebrow-raising. And am sure the policy makers have factored all these into the policy.
Never mind. anything with a noble purpose is always welcome. No matter how much of a penny goes to the beneficiary, it MUST go there.
Dear mr sibal, expand higher education with excellence and equity, bring in as many Harvards, Standfords, Sloans,etc to India.......but the greater need will always remain at the bottom of the pyramid.......so let SSA, MSA (?) and HE be naturally be supplementing each other and each one automatically providing the womb for the succeeding ones and be in sync with each other.
Lets also get real and understand that up in ladder, education (higher) is not for all, and not all would opt for education...hence we must have ample avenues for earning livelihood...the Skill mission is just abt the right kind if thing to meet this need. Its for us to wait and see what fruits all these policy initiatives are gonna bear.........but, am quite hopeful....Lets give time some time....... cheers
Any ways, better late than never.with ppl like m m singh and kapil sibal at the helm of affairs, i have reasons to believe that the education landscape of India wud be like never before. nowithstanding what oppsn wud say, what some fanatic activists wud say, sibal seems to be in a hurry. and his being in a hurry gets my 'thumbs up'. man, u have the balls to do things this way.
however, we keep on hearing abt tall talks on 'balanced growth', 'social democracy', 'participatory development' and guess what, 4 days ago a friend asked me - what is 'positive development'..boy oh boy- what non-sensical things we guys are into !!!
Don't we realise its time we did the talk......enuf of talking and walking the talks..
With right to education all set to boost the GER ( Gross enrolment ratio) what confuses me is the meeting of RTE and 'compulsory education-CE'...Does this 'compulsory' element invite punishment for parents for not sending their children to schools? Does this also imply punitive action against primary school teachers for not getting eligible kids in their catchment areas to the schools? will RTE and CE put together create rooms for more corrupt practices? will the 'learning aid', 'food', etc reach the beneficiaries or will this mean more money for you-know-who ?
Many such questions are not eyebrow-raising. And am sure the policy makers have factored all these into the policy.
Never mind. anything with a noble purpose is always welcome. No matter how much of a penny goes to the beneficiary, it MUST go there.
Dear mr sibal, expand higher education with excellence and equity, bring in as many Harvards, Standfords, Sloans,etc to India.......but the greater need will always remain at the bottom of the pyramid.......so let SSA, MSA (?) and HE be naturally be supplementing each other and each one automatically providing the womb for the succeeding ones and be in sync with each other.
Lets also get real and understand that up in ladder, education (higher) is not for all, and not all would opt for education...hence we must have ample avenues for earning livelihood...the Skill mission is just abt the right kind if thing to meet this need. Its for us to wait and see what fruits all these policy initiatives are gonna bear.........but, am quite hopeful....Lets give time some time....... cheers
Tuesday, July 28, 2009
Saturday, July 11, 2009
Was Adam made for Eve only, or for Steve also?
The hungama surrounding the reading down of article 377 by the Delhi High Court has been selling like a hot cake in e-media. Kuchh bhi kaho- it has divided the country down the middle inviting sharp reactions from different walks of life.
It was sheer fun to watch Suhel Seth shouting his sh** out on the custodians of Indian religions (they claim so!!! ) couple of days ago on one of the news channels. Suhel baba, calm down. You don’t need to call them “bizarre’!
Is it really to do with the larger question of whether India is ready to come to terms with ‘modern’ times? I don’t know. But hearing the arguments and counter arguments on whether it is ‘ok’ to decriminalize consensual sex between two adults of same sex, I was left scratching my head. Well, did not really find anything ‘convincing’. So thought of just sitting back and waiting for the next round of hearing at the apex court.
However, personally I feel it was too early/premature for the Naaz folks to celebrate the way they did. At the very outset, it looked like a welcome move by the Delhi high court. But then the parade was little too over-the-top, as if a nation got freedom from a foreign reign.
Whatever an adult (defined legally in India) does inside his/her bedroom should NOT be anyone’s business! But then, getting on to the street to go ga-ga over the private life was little too much. I am not quite sure whether homosexuality gets sanction from any religious code of conduct(?). But nothing legal should not write off an adult of his/her choice.
It was so funny to hear the astrologer guy (some Kaushal from delhi) who has filed the recent petition against the ruling (it seems to be his 30 seconds to fame). He said and I quote “even animals do get indulged in this kind of act”..wow what a piece of wisdom. He apparently means human beings should do what animals do…..God bless him. By the way, animals don’t care for mothers and sisters when it comes to sex. Doesn’t Mr Kaushal know that?
Baba Ram dev (another wise man on the planet) considers homosexuality as a disease..wow, baba, now you get another chance to sell your medicines (?)…are these people feeling insecure??? Baba, you cannot weed out a set of people that you are uncomfortable with. By the way, is celibacy a ‘good’ thing? Isn’t it unnatural?
Look what Mahabharata says, “repay your debt to your ancestors by procreating”. And it was so big a statement that in case of Pandu, it was expected and ok to send his wife to a stranger to get impregnated by him.
Religion seems to be having headway into anything and everything in this country. Well am not surprised any longer. But then we have to say at some point in time that it’s enough. Give the progressive Indians a break. How can a religion (which one has not chosen for him/herself as his/her identity) govern everything about someone’s life. Forget about its take on homosexuality. It’s been there in every sphere of one’s life. Why can’t we just let religion alone as a ‘belief’. And moral policing??? Boy oh boy!!! This country has millions of such people. The Managalore pub incident is still fresh in people’s memory. A bunch of people will decide whether a girl should or should not go to a pub!!! What rubbish!!!
I don’t have a problem with who the other guy is sleeping with as long as that not hampering my life. And hey, on a lighter note- I think India should promote this same sex marriage. I think that’s the only solution for growing population (am sure many would agree that population is the root cause of all the problem in India, at least the health minister who feels that people should delay marriage and people should remain awake watching TV in order to stay away from bed as much as possible !!!)
The real question here is not whether gayness is a disease or not, socially acceptable or not. The courts judgment had nothing to do with that. It's about individual liberty: can the government tell you where to stick your junk? Time has changed (or let me say- is changing). So everything else has to alter in order to maintain pace. It’s as simple as that.
It was sheer fun to watch Suhel Seth shouting his sh** out on the custodians of Indian religions (they claim so!!! ) couple of days ago on one of the news channels. Suhel baba, calm down. You don’t need to call them “bizarre’!
Is it really to do with the larger question of whether India is ready to come to terms with ‘modern’ times? I don’t know. But hearing the arguments and counter arguments on whether it is ‘ok’ to decriminalize consensual sex between two adults of same sex, I was left scratching my head. Well, did not really find anything ‘convincing’. So thought of just sitting back and waiting for the next round of hearing at the apex court.
However, personally I feel it was too early/premature for the Naaz folks to celebrate the way they did. At the very outset, it looked like a welcome move by the Delhi high court. But then the parade was little too over-the-top, as if a nation got freedom from a foreign reign.
Whatever an adult (defined legally in India) does inside his/her bedroom should NOT be anyone’s business! But then, getting on to the street to go ga-ga over the private life was little too much. I am not quite sure whether homosexuality gets sanction from any religious code of conduct(?). But nothing legal should not write off an adult of his/her choice.
It was so funny to hear the astrologer guy (some Kaushal from delhi) who has filed the recent petition against the ruling (it seems to be his 30 seconds to fame). He said and I quote “even animals do get indulged in this kind of act”..wow what a piece of wisdom. He apparently means human beings should do what animals do…..God bless him. By the way, animals don’t care for mothers and sisters when it comes to sex. Doesn’t Mr Kaushal know that?
Baba Ram dev (another wise man on the planet) considers homosexuality as a disease..wow, baba, now you get another chance to sell your medicines (?)…are these people feeling insecure??? Baba, you cannot weed out a set of people that you are uncomfortable with. By the way, is celibacy a ‘good’ thing? Isn’t it unnatural?
Look what Mahabharata says, “repay your debt to your ancestors by procreating”. And it was so big a statement that in case of Pandu, it was expected and ok to send his wife to a stranger to get impregnated by him.
Religion seems to be having headway into anything and everything in this country. Well am not surprised any longer. But then we have to say at some point in time that it’s enough. Give the progressive Indians a break. How can a religion (which one has not chosen for him/herself as his/her identity) govern everything about someone’s life. Forget about its take on homosexuality. It’s been there in every sphere of one’s life. Why can’t we just let religion alone as a ‘belief’. And moral policing??? Boy oh boy!!! This country has millions of such people. The Managalore pub incident is still fresh in people’s memory. A bunch of people will decide whether a girl should or should not go to a pub!!! What rubbish!!!
I don’t have a problem with who the other guy is sleeping with as long as that not hampering my life. And hey, on a lighter note- I think India should promote this same sex marriage. I think that’s the only solution for growing population (am sure many would agree that population is the root cause of all the problem in India, at least the health minister who feels that people should delay marriage and people should remain awake watching TV in order to stay away from bed as much as possible !!!)
The real question here is not whether gayness is a disease or not, socially acceptable or not. The courts judgment had nothing to do with that. It's about individual liberty: can the government tell you where to stick your junk? Time has changed (or let me say- is changing). So everything else has to alter in order to maintain pace. It’s as simple as that.
Friday, July 10, 2009
Passions
Three passions have governed my life:
The longings for love, the search for knowledge,
And unbearable pity for the suffering of [humankind].
Love brings ecstasy and relieves loneliness.
In the union of love I have seen
In a mystic miniature the prefiguring vision
Of the heavens that saints and poets have imagined.
With equal passion I have sought knowledge.
I have wished to understand the hearts of [people].
I have wished to know why the stars shine.
Love and knowledge led upwards to the heavens,
But always pity brought me back to earth;
Cries of pain reverberated in my heart
Of children in famine, of victims tortured
And of old people left helpless.
I long to alleviate the evil, but I cannot,
And I too suffer.
This has been my life; I found it worth living ( adopted from B Russel)
The longings for love, the search for knowledge,
And unbearable pity for the suffering of [humankind].
Love brings ecstasy and relieves loneliness.
In the union of love I have seen
In a mystic miniature the prefiguring vision
Of the heavens that saints and poets have imagined.
With equal passion I have sought knowledge.
I have wished to understand the hearts of [people].
I have wished to know why the stars shine.
Love and knowledge led upwards to the heavens,
But always pity brought me back to earth;
Cries of pain reverberated in my heart
Of children in famine, of victims tortured
And of old people left helpless.
I long to alleviate the evil, but I cannot,
And I too suffer.
This has been my life; I found it worth living ( adopted from B Russel)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)